Tuesday, August 7, 2012

Your subject and personal style in photography

I am an amateur photographer who is completely self taught. Admittedly, that is not saying much; I believe the quality of my photographs fall in the "okayish to decent" category, so I've achieved probably as much as a million other self taught amateur photographers. But, I really want to change that; I would want to decrease that number of people who can be compared to me to 10,000 maybe, self taught or not (one can dream, right?). After about 4-5 years of doing photography, my interested gravitated towards "controlled" studio photography and bought some studio equipment last year, to practice. (I've since realized that even in studio photography, "complete control" is an illusion. There is always luck involved).

One of the things that I've been reading quite often lately is the importance of personal style. Most recently, this article at Luminous Landscape discusses why personal style is important. Personal style is what differentiates you from any other photographer. If you and any other photographer is put under exactly the same conditions, both of you would probably come back with very different pictures. That is personal style.

Now, how do you go about finding your personal style? Probably the first thing you do is get inspired from others' work. That is really helpful in general to improve photography, but I found that to be of little help in trying to find personal style. I've probably found more success just thinking in my mind what I want to photograph next, and trying to set it up. One example of it is in the following picture: It is an attempt to have an early morning feeling with window light, but is actually taken in a studio at 10.30 pm in the night! There is no window in that direction.

Early morning looks from Aditi (click on image for larger version).
I tried to analyze why this photo works as intended: Firstly, there is of course the soft light which looks like there is a window just outside the frame. But the real reason is the combination of clothes, unmade hair and the ruffled instead of stretched curtains in the back. Her expression that looks like she is interested in what is outside adds to the overall idea (this is the luck part - only one in about 30 photos had this expression). Editing this photo was really simple: I took the RAW out of the camera and simply selected one of B&W presets in Lightroom.

This analysis also made me realize one thing: your subject and the environment makes or breaks the photo. Great sensor, great lens, and even great lighting will fail you if your subject is boring. And if you think about all the great photographs in history, you'll realize they are loved mainly because of their subject (look at these for e.g.: Afghan girl, Pepper #30, Girl holding kitten, Man jumping over puddle). It has motivated me to put more and more effort into setting up what is in front of my camera. Frankly speaking, though this realization looks very obvious, it is very easy to get lost in the whole technique (lighting is technique too) and editing it differently routine. The current fad of "Art" Filters like cross processing or miniaturization is one example.

Coming back the question of personal style, I think I've at least found a direction. I am going to take studio photos of people (or, rather, photos in controlled lighting), but I want people never to describe it as studio photo of someone. No more headshots on a white background. No more beauty shots. Instead, setup ever more unexpected scenes in front of the camera. Where the picture makes sense, but something one would not expect to see based on a verbal description, say. One great example I found recently for the above idea is the following photo of Olympic gymnast Gabby Douglas by Martin Schoeller:

A great example of an unexpected visual setup but still displaying the dexterity of the gymnast. Click on the image to see more images of Olympic athletes from the same photographer.






Inventing technology vs market segment


One of the most widely discussed topics in the tech world is the patent warfare that is happening in the smartphone and tablet world. I specifically want to discuss the ongoing Apple vs Samsung patent case being discussed over their tablets. This case has taken the limelight for many reasons; it is one of the few cases which has went on to the stage of jury based trial, and also because it has revealed interesting facts about inside workings of Apple. But there is also widespread disagreement if that the case actually has any merit.

It is widely acknowledged that Apple really invented the modern smartphone. It created a device which was completely about touch, using no stylus. It designed and implemented a smooth and intuitive user interface totally from ground up. After that, anybody who didn't have a touchscreen smartphone like that was immediately relegated to the last generation. There was definitely a lot of invention going on around here - starting from the electronics of the device to the design and, crucially, the smooth implementation of the the UI.

A couple of years later, Apple released the iPad. Unlike in the case of iPhone, iPad was largely rejected by the media in the time between it was announced and it was actually released in the market. Everyone said it was a large iPod touch, and will never sell. But turns out, just the different screen size makes all the difference. Though the UI was mostly same, access to larger screen space makes web surfing easier, and viewing photos and movies more pleasurable. But, here is the big question: was there any new technology in the iPad? Was iPad an invention? I don't believe so. Apple showed the world that there is use and there is market for a touchscreen device with a larger screen. It did a great implementation of the device, with most people agreeing that is still the case. But an invention, like the iPhone, it was not.

Then why is the Apple vs Samsung tablet case a patent battle? The only possible patent that can be new in the case of tablets is probably the design of the device. The Wired magazine recently discussed few of the patents covered in this exact trial. Here is one of the drawings from Apple's iPad patent. I am not sure how you reacted on seeing it, but I just went wow! There is absolutely nothing specific about that design.

The second thing that people don't really factor in into these discussions is the effort required in the implementation. People think that once you have the idea, implementation is easy. That is simply not true: implementation is really hard to do. Android itself is the biggest example: From version 1 to version 2.3 (Gingerbread), overall Android was not as good as the iOS. Nexus One with Android 2.2 (Froyo) was still much more inconsistent than the iPhone 4 - both in terms of design of small operations and in the performance of the UI and the apps. And I am sure Google must have had to work really hard to bring Android to what it is now in the form of Jelly Bean. Punishing Samsung simply because it chose a similar shaped rectangle is really an injustice to all the Samsung engineers who've worked hard to do its implementation. Even with their work, Apple iPad is still the better device; I've used both Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1 and iPad 2 and assure you Samsung's Honeycomb tablet had really bad performance in comparison to the iPad. Apple enjoys a monopoly like market share in the tablet market not without reason. Samsung is getting exactly what they deserve directly from the market.

Eventually, I am sure Apple must have realized that it is next to impossible to eliminate its main competitors from the market through patents. People will design around the patents. My guess is that Apple wants the public to think that the competitors are stealing its inventions. And going through the comments on many tech news sites and blogs, that really seems to be working. Their official line about how others "must not steal their inventions" is pretty catchy too!


Tuesday, June 19, 2012

Small cameras for serious photographers



Having recently bought a new camera, I am still riding the excitement wave and I continue to spend a lot of time thinking about photos I want to take and reading online about photography (equipment, tips and looking at great photos by others). As part of this excitement, here is another post about photography - on equipment which I believe hasn't been getting as much attention as it deserves.

If you want to take seriously good pictures, you'll be most likely be recommended a DSLR, most probably a Nikon or a Canon. Which is not wrong at all as both companies make excellent cameras at all price ranges. The sales figures reflect this - entry level Canon and Nikon DSLRs are among the largest selling cameras in the world.

But I've seen many people complain that these cameras are bigger than they would like to carry everywhere. These people not professional photographers, so its not like they lose money by not carrying their cameras. What they lose is a number of interesting opportunities to get a good photograph. And even for pros sometimes smaller size helps.

Thus, I've compiled a list of some great recent cameras that can replace your DSLRs giving your similar image quality and many other features at similar price, but are much more smaller. All these cameras are 'mirrorless' which means that they don't have a mirror to reflect the image formed by the lens into the optical viewfinder of an SLR (this is the definition of an Single Lens Reflex cameras), and this is what makes them small. To compose the image, only electronic finder is made available - which is either just the LCD on the back or sometimes an EVF (Electronic View Finder) which is useful in bright light. The reason they offer image quality at similar level to modern DSLRs is because of their large sensors (read more about sensor sizes here: http://www.cambridgeincolour.com/tutorials/digital-camera-sensor-size.htm).

Here is a comparison of the camera I bought, the Olympus E-M5, with the Canon Rebel DSLR, for size. The cameras listed below are similar in size to the E-M5 or even smaller.

Photo credit - dpreview.com

The camera names in headings below are linked to the dpreview.com review page of that camera.

Panasonic G3




Belonging to the Micro Four Thirds standard (for which Olympus also makes cameras), this is one of the best value cameras that exist in the market. It is a traditional DSLR styled camera which has an integrated EVF. It has a 16 MP sensor which has really image quality - almost as good as DSLRs like Nikon D5100. One of the best things about Micro Four Thirds standard is that the lenses for this system are also very small. One of the most highly recommended lenses is the Panasonic 20mm f/1.7, which is so small, its called a 'pancake' lens!

Sony NEX-5N



This the mid range model in the Sony's relatively new NEX range. It has a 16MP APS-C size sensor (same as Nikon DX size) and its image quality is thus just as good as the Nikon or Canon DSLRs and slightly better than the Panasonic G3 above. But the downsides include no inbuilt EVF and that the lenses are not quite as small as the cameras itself. The lens range is also a bit small right now. Overall, though, this has some of the best image quality for the money and size, and its no wonder it got a Gold award from dpreview.com.

Nikon J1



This is the Nikon's entry in the mirrorless market and has its own pros and cons. It uses a 1" sensor which is smaller than both Micro Four Thirds and APS-C sensors. It makes do with 10MP whereas most of its competitors have 12 or 16 MP (but I believe 10MP is enough for most), and its low light image quality is not as good either. Though, it's still a big step up from the compact cameras which have much smaller sensors and is good enough for indoor photography. Its biggest plus point is its picture taking speed and its Auto Focus system - its blazing fast and gets you accurately focused pictures even when your subject is moving fast or erratically.

Sony RX100




This is the latest camera from Sony and isn't even available for purchase yet. It features a 1" sensor like the Nikon J1, and packs 20MP instead of 10 in the Nikon. But unlike other cameras mentioned here, it has a fixed lens. Early reports suggest that its image quality is very good. Among other things Sony emphasizes is its control system (the ring around the lens rotates to change settings like shutter speed or aperture) and its fast Auto Focus speeds. Of course, the real reason to consider this camera is that it packs all that in a really small size - its in the same league as compact cameras like Canon S100, Panasonic LX5 or Olympus XZ-1. If you didn't think you'd ever buy other lenses with DSLRs or want a second camera to take carry everywhere, this looks like the best option currently available.

Monday, June 4, 2012

Why I bought the Olympus E-M5 instead of Nikon D7000?



After thinking about what camera to buy for the last week or so, I bought the Olympus E-M5. This means a shift of systems for me because I've been using a Nikon D40 for last 5 years. I currently have 3 AF Nikon mount lenses: Sigma 18-200mm, Nikon 35mm f/1.8 and Tamron 60mm f/2 Macro (which I use for portrait), all bought within last 2 years. Plus a couple of old MF lenses: 50mm f/1.8 and 75-150mm f/3.5 E series lenses which I occasionally use. It would seem foolish to change systems, especially considering the excellence of latest Nikon cameras.

Why, then, did I still decide to change my primary system? Simply because I wanted a camera which is with me more of the times and allows me to the take good pictures in all situations. The olympus got chosen over D7000 mainly because its much smaller. I currently also own the Olympus E-PL1 (which I'll obviously sell now). Though I don't like that camera much as compared to Nikon D40 (slower and erratic AF, slightly worse high ISO image quality), I carry that camera more often simply because its small. E-M5 is very similar in size. Both E-M5 and D7000 are better than D40 in other respects:

  • Magnesium alloy weather sealed body. Twice the Nikon D40 has given up on me at crucial moments because it got wet (Hogenakkal falls and Lake Tahoe. Lake Tahoe incident is the reason I had to buy E-PL1). The E-M5 feels very solid and a bit heavy for its size.
  • Larger, higher resolution screen on the back.
  • Much faster AF and more focus points for manual selection. Having only 3 focus points in D40 is a frequent pain. The AF speed on E-M5 is simply amazing!
  • Olympus EVF is better to have than the Nikon D40 viewfinder - its bigger, brighter and shows a lot more info. Of course, the D7000 viewfinder trumps all and is one of the ways Nikon beats the Olympus.
  • Live view, with Olympus having a tiltable screen. Helps when camera is mounted on tripod. Also helps in rare situations when I need to focus manually. Olympus actually has a touchscreen which has touch to click feature - I predict this will be frequently used in studio when camera is on tripod. Right now, though, it  only helps takes pictures when I don't want to, so I've assigned it to touch to focus.
  • Video is not high on my priority list, but there have been times I wanted a video and had to use my phone even when I had the D40.
  • Another feature I don't usually use but can be helpful: Faster continuous shooting rates (6fps on Nikon, 9fps on Olympus).
Of course, one of the biggest reasons for upgrade is the image quality. And that's the critical reason why Olympus got chosen. It's image quality is almost there with Nikon D7000. And Nikon D7000 probably has the best image quality for APS-C sensors (only the new Fujifilm X-Pro1 beats it convincingly). And for me, its more than adequate. Had Olympus put the same sensor as E-PL1 in E-M5, it would've never made the cut. I am not looking for the last iota of improvement in image quality, but rather the other usability features of the camera as long as an image quality bar is met. First impressions suggest that the image quality improvement is no magic bullet as I had assumed before buying. But still, ISO 3200-4000 should see regular use and ISO 5000 is also pretty usable. The picture below is at ISO 5000 (RAW, has seen minor adjustments for tone and colour, plus a little bit of noise reduction in Lightroom).

IIT Madras junta at the Biere Club in Bangalore
There are other factors:

  • Lens selection: Nikon simply walks over Micro Four Thirds (MFT) here. But crucially, if I had the money and I wanted to buy 4 lenses right now, MFT has all of them (20mm f/1.7, 40-150mm f/4-5.6, 45mm f/1.8, 7-14mm f/4 if my budget ever allows). The shining stars of Nikon lens range are anyways hopelessly out of my budget (like 85mm f/1.4, 200mm f/2)
  • Image Stabilization/Vibration Reduction: Olympus has in body system which works with all lenses. And the implementation in E-M5 is excellent and as good as VR in most Nikon lenses. Combined with lack of mirror shake and the high ISO capabilities over Nikon D40, I think I am able to take usable shots in light levels 3-4 EV less than before. The picture below was taken handheld, with elbows resting on a table, at 1s shutter speed! Its a JPEG out of the camera with a bit of colour correction.
  • Battery life: Nikon will usually not consume power for framing with its optical finder, but Olympus always does with its electronic finder. This makes Nikon last upto 3 times longer on a battery charge. Something I'll have to live with by buying backup batteries (I've also started to keep at least one backup camera on trips where photography is important).


Just after purchasing the camera, at Blue Ginger restaurant in Bangalore. The actual light levels were much darker than what it looks like in the image above.

I wondered that if money was no object, what camera system would I buy if I could own only one. Nothing from Nikon because anything better than D7000 is also bigger. Similarly no to Canon. Fujifilm X-Pro1 would've been a great option, but it doesn't have a standard zoom right now, its slow AF speed can be frustrating and has no built in flash. Compact cameras have poor image quality, medium format is way too large, bad in low light etc. Pentax Q has almost compact like image quality, and its K-01 is too large for mirrorless. Sony's NEX range is good and its especially tempting to use M mount lenses with the help of its focus peaking feature, but has very few good (and large) E system lenses and no weather sealed body (it was the closest competitor though). Leica M9 maybe? Lack of AF lenses and zooms have multiple problems - zoom and AF are user friendly and it also means I can't assume anyone else will be able to use the camera (sometimes, I like being in the photograph too :-) ). Don't judge me negatively here - I like using primes and manual focus if its well implemented, but would feel constrained if they were the only choice for the only camera I own. Thus, it seems the camera I bought is the best camera in the money no object scenario!

I'm still keeping my Nikon kit. I would never get rid of Nikon D40 I suppose, it has become an emotional attachment now, being the primary moment capturing device for the last 5 years. Also, it's working as well as when it was new, even after getting dunked in water twice. As for the lenses, I still have hope that Nikon will someday give me a smaller body to attach those to (Nikon 1 doesn't count). Or if I get richer, I may be invested in 2 upto date systems at the same time. I will sell the 18-200mm though, I don't expect it to see any use now.

Lastly, buying a new camera has made me excited over photography again. My studio equipment was lying unused for months but this week I started to practise again. Equipment might not be the biggest reason behind quality photos, but it does motivate the photographer if it's enjoyable to use.

Tuesday, January 10, 2012

Fujifilm to go mainstream?

Fujifilm can never be called a traditional camera company. It has always been the one to find niches - some of its most famous cameras, including in the film era, barely had any peers: 6x7 Rangefinder, TX-1 Panaromic Rangefinder (more famous as Hasselblad Xpan), and even the recent X100 had just one competitor in the form Leica X1. But their latest camera announcement puts them in direct competition with what is becoming the staple offerings from Olympus, Panasonic, Sony, Samsung etc. and hottest new camera segment - mirrorless interchangeable lens cameras.



Fujifilm has just announced the X-Pro1 camera, part of its new X-Series system. At first glance, this camera is largely similar to other offerings - 16M APS-C sensor, contrast detect autofocus and back LCD and EVF to compose. But delve just a bit deeper and Fujifilm's desire to remain different clearly shows:

  • fixed focal length optical viewfinder with rangefinder like brightlines, along with an EVF
  • aperture ring on the lenses
  • the fact they are launching with 3 lenses, all of which are primes
  • thoroughly old school and drool worthy looks

There are more innovations - for e.g. they claim a new colour array in the sensor whereby moire is reduced without using a low pass filter (which removes very fine detail from photos). If you understand why moire occurs in the Bayer array, it is clear that periodic arrangement of pixels is the main reason. Fujifilm, instead of letting the colour pixels repeating regularly throughout the sensor, have made blocks of 6x6 pixels inside of which the different coloured pixels are randomly arranged. Clever stuff!

Do we have the king of mirrorless?
Looks like the new Fuji has all the ingredients for success - they are already known for making well built cameras (latest X10 and X100 are the best examples), their imaging pipelines have generally been great - from lens till image processing, and they are bringing a host of innovations along with their traditional strengths. What could go wrong? Well, a few things can:
  • User interface: As good as the X100 was, it was universally panned for its poor user interface. Fujifilm claims a new paradigm for X-Pro1 - let's hope they nail it this time.
  • Stuff not mentioned in the highlights: stuff like autofocus speed and accuracy, or even poor battery life can sometimes become a big problem.
  • Lack of standard zoom: It launches without one. This may be a short lived issue, though, as their roadmap indicates zoom lenses are to be introduced in 2012 itself.
  • High price: Judging from the high prices of X100 and X10 and barely any concession made here to keep the costs in control - it doesn't look like this one's going to be cheap. Expect upwards of $1500 for the body alone.
How many more years of Leica M?
Leica M series has been braving the digital world with some difficulties. There is no doubt that its latest offering, the M9, can take spectacular photos, particularly due to its brilliant lenses. Its bright rangefinder window is often praised to greatly aid composition. But its defining characteristic is also its biggest problem - being a rangefinder it has no autofocus and no zoom lenses (and no live view, no video capture ... the list is long). And no matter how much Leica fanboys say that these features are not required, they can't convince the modern generation.

In general, the Fujifilm, and the modern technology in general, can take on everything that Leica offers. Fujifilm has a history of making great lenses, and the lenses available at launch shows that Fujifilm cares about prime loving market - a category into which every Leica lover falls into. The hybrid viewfinder technology can give the same benefits as Leica M's large rangefinder window (without, of course, the focus mechanism itself). And there is no doubt that the X-Pro1 will be built to a standard.

Leica M cameras have perennially been an object of desire for enthusiasts, but very few can really afford it. This is a new system which can replicate all the charm of the Leica M, has all the modern conveniences, and costs a fraction of its price! Time to start saving :-)

Thursday, December 29, 2011

Google+ now equivalent to Android in 2009?

One of the news items I read today was about the estimation that Google+ now has 62 million users. Considering it was about 40 million in October, this number looks about right. This may make it the fastest growing social network ever, but its still a david to the goliath that is Facebook.

One of the things that the post mentions is the network effect - that as more people use it, its inherent value increases as a social network, hence it will add users at greater speed. That means that growth will be "super linear", the visualization of which is sometimes called the hockey stick graph. Now, where have I seen such a graph before...


Android, of course! Android was a relatively slow starter. This changed soon, though, and due to the huge marketing that went with the first Verizon Droid, and the availability of android phones from many manufacturers for all carriers, it got a strong kick. It may or may not have been the best phone OS, but it provided different things to different people - they were available with or without physical keyboards, small and big, cheap or expensive etc.

How does this all relate to Google+? Because the biggest reason for Android's hockey stick growth is the same as is being predicted for Google+. The reason is that increasing usage drives even more adoption. People see their friends using Androids and buy them. Manufacturers and carriers put more effort into their range, developing better quality phones with a wider range of features and specifications. And most importantly, developers consider it an important platform to support.

Of course, all this growth must be supported by real development and innovation in the platform. It is clear that Android has shown that - the UI has improved with every new release, its implementation of notifications and multitasking cannot be beaten, its the only platform that supports the new 4G networks, and the only real supporter of third party innovation like in the form of amazing Swype and SwiftKeyX keyboards. Google+, one can argue, is following this trend - Hangouts keeps adding interesting new features, Google+ search is amazing, and I really like the privacy model which prevents me from reading all the spam (updates not meant for me) at Facebook. Every new improvement to Google+ will pull in more users, and some day its usage will reach critical mass, after which its hockey stick growth is all but guaranteed.



Tuesday, December 6, 2011

Chromebook silently successful?


I was looking at amazon.com today to look for a laptop, and saw that Acer's chromebook is actually at number 5 in the bestseller's list. Its a pretty surprising find because I remember when the Samsung's chromebook was launched, it was universally panned by reviewers and media (save engadget). If you search for a chromebook, you will see that all of them are rated a solid 4 stars.

Why is that the media reacted so different from actual users? The biggest argument that media had against chromebook was that for the same price you could buy a windows netbook which could do so much more. But it seems actual users are not looking to do so much more. Connectivity requirement was a big negative. But we are almost always connected. Most reviews of the chromebook laud its ease of use. They say that it may not replace someone's primary computer, but 90% of the use case is just using the internet for which it works very well. With decent hardware and good battery life, to me it all seems like a recipe for success.

Media inconsistent in their reviews?

When you look at the mobile rivalry between iOS and Android, the blogosphere generally tends to favour iOS, citing ease of use being more important than sheer number of features. Why is it, then, that in the case of chromebook ease of use and less features is a worse combination than a more complicated interface and more features? Frankly, I don't know. It maybe the case that most tech writers use a lot of windows or mac software, which obviously don't have any chrome OS equivalents, and therefore couldn't imagine themselves using them. But then, reviewers should be able to put themselves in the shoes of potential users when reviewing the product and not just use their own profile to judge a product.

Whatever the reason, it seems like media can't predict every trend. And when buying something for yourself, it always pays to do some work yourself to know if the product fits your needs.

Friday, October 28, 2011

Manufacturer Android UI skins have failed

Samsung's TouchWiz UI Skin for Android

The open source nature of Android has many potential advantages. It allows absolutely anyone to create a device which will have a good amount of functionality, well thought out software, availability of a large number of apps for the platform, etc. Ideally, this should mean that hardware manufacturers can concentrate on one thing - the hardware. They can build devices with beautiful looking and well built body, which have good screens, great battery life, fast performance, different form factors etc. Or they can offer cheap phones which have never before heard features for their price.

But, for some reason, the manufacturers have decided to devote much of their attention on improving the software instead. The software, which is already being worked on by over 100 brilliant engineers and great UI designers, is where they feel there is real need for work. This has created the famous problem of fragmentation, where users don't have access to latest android features because the manufacturers/carriers don't update the software for their phones after Google has released a new version of android, and where developers have to work harder so that their apps can run on as many devices as possible.

My question is: has there been a positive, for consumers, for all the work manufacturers have put on customizing android? I can think of few niche features, like "unlock to an app" in HTC Sense or improved cut/copy/paste in Samsung's TouchWiz. On the other hand, they add a bucket full of bloatware - for e.g., Samsung has its own book reader, its own Social feed app, even their own app store on their Android phones. They are much worse than their main competitors, like Kindle for Android app or Android Market. Their Samsung Galaxy S2 has been creating a lot of buzz in the smartphone market last few months, but I can't think of a single way how their customized software has contributed to that buzz. It is popular because of its fantastic hardware - fast performance, beautiful screen, brilliant camera, exceptionally thin design and better than average battery life. It should really serve the lesson that I gave in the beginning of this post: concentrate on hardware!

Screenshots from the latest Android version, Ice Cream Sandwich

I bought Samsung Galaxy S2 a couple of months back because its hardware had smitten me and it looked like a big upgrade from my Nexus S. It runs gingerbread, and being their current flagship, I am very sure they will update it to the newly released Ice Cream Sandwich (ICS) in some reasonable amount of time (otherwise, their reputation will be forever damaged). This got me thinking: what part of their TouchWiz Android skin, if retained, would be an useful addition over ICS? The answer: I can come up with absolutely nothing! TouchWiz fixed a few issues here and there over Gingerbread (like using page thumbnails while switching tabs in browser), but now the new vanilla android release fixes them (and does much more!) in a much better way. If the manufacturers have any sense (pun intended), they will start using vanilla ICS build, with probably a few additions in the form of apps. At some point they should realize that they cannot, and should not, compete with Google in terms of UI design and software features. For their own good.


Wednesday, October 26, 2011

Is Nokia Lumia 800 Windows Phone flagship?

The newly launched Nokia Lumia 800, their first Windows Phone.


Nokia launched their much anticipated Windows Phone device today, the Lumia 800. Unsurprisingly, it looks nearly identical to the Meego phone they launched some time back, the N9. The media has been looking forward the Lumia 800 assuming that will become the flagship for the Windows Phone ecosystem; like it's the nexus series of Windows Phone. But has it delivered? Is the device any better than other upcoming Windows Phone 7.5 (Mango) devices? We try to find out, by comparing it with the Samsung Focus S.

Samsung Focus S, an upcoming Windows based Phone.


  • Design and Looks - Nokia has a history of designing phone with a special eye towards design, and Lumia 800 shows that. Its has beautiful minimalist looks, and it is practically identical to N9 externally, it should be very well built. Samsung Focus S, on the other hand, has ordinary (read: drab) looks, and they are not known to build very solid feeling devices. That said, it has one ace up its sleeve, its very low thickness - 8.55mm vs Nokia's 12.1mm.
  • Screen - Nokia has a 3.7" Clearblack AMOLED screen, compared to a 4.3" Super AMOLED Plus screen on the Samsung Focus S. Both screens have been seen on earlier devices (N9 and Samsung Galaxy S2), and it looks like its a dead heat when it comes to colour saturation, brightness and contrast between the two screens. Both have identical overall resolution. I think the larger size of the Samsung Focus S has the edge here.
  • Camera - Both phones have an 8MP still camera, though the video capture resolution is different - 720p for Nokia vs 1080p on the Samsung. Nokia has a history of making great cameras, and they use their partnership with Carl Zeiss to put a branded lens on Nokia Lumia 800. Samsung's camera should be great too, as we've already seen spectacular performance from its Galaxy S2. Samsung also has a front camera, which the Nokia Lumia 800 lacks - this is potentially a significant advantage for those who make video calls, especially since Skype is promised on the Mango OS by Microsoft.
  • Battery Life - Nokia has announced the specs for its battery at 1450mAh. Samsung has not released the specs, but we can assume its going to be upwards of 1700mAh (again, using the Galaxy S2 analogy). Both phones should be nearly identical in their battery consumptions as both use the same chip and run the same OS, with screen size being the major differentiator. I expect practical battery life to be similar on both devices.
  • Software - Nokia has been able to add a few additions to the Windows Mango 7.5 OS, most significant of those being the Nokia Drive. It is Nokia's version of maps with turn by turn navigation. Nokia Maps also allows offline downloading of Maps Data. I use Android's turn by turn navigation many times on my Samsung Galaxy S2, and this gives a noticeable advantage to Nokia here (one advantage which it also has over the iPhone). Nokia also has its own music store. Samsung has no additions to the stock OS.
Going through the above comparison, it is no longer obvious that Nokia is in any way the flagship Windows Phone device. The biggest difference is its cute looks (including availability in 3 colours) and smaller screen size, which means women will probably choose this over the Samsung. But with the larger screen and front camera, there will be many who will prefer the Focus S.

Of course, they have to compete with iPhone and Android phones, both of which are now available in most stores. Microsoft went to great lengths to make Nokia their partner (allegedly even paying them $1 billion). But it doesn't look like Nokia has responded with a phone which might be worth that effort. That said, Nokia has some other advantages, like their enormous retail presence in Europe and Asia. In India, for example, Nokia is still the favoured brand of many who associate it with well built phones with great battery life, and despise Samsung for its cheap feeling phones. With proper marketing, Nokia might be able to sell their Windows Phone devices over not only Samsung and HTC Windows Phone devices, but even their Android ones. Who knows, this might have been the exact reason for their marriage.

Saturday, October 22, 2011

Android Ice Cream Sandwich vs iOS 5.0 UI comparison



As far as I know, this is a first objective and detailed comparison of usability between Android and iOS. This discussion limits itself only to the software UI when applied to phones.

My first observation, I made when I first had a hands-on with a honeycomb device (Motorola Xoom, which sucks by the way), is how much the modern Windows UI, first shown in Windows 95, is similar to Android UI.

Honeycomb tablet home screen
Windows 7 Desktop
The similarities:
  • Desktop vs Home screens
  • Alt-Tab or Windows-Tab to switch apps vs App Switcher in Honeycomb
  • Non-intrusive notifications at the right bottom in both.
  • Start button vs App Drawer (though, on the opposite ends of the screen)
  • Desktop widgets in Windows vs Widgets on home screens
  • Free development - run any app developed for it (agreed, not UI).
Lets get started with our deep dive.

Android scores over iOS:

1. Home screens are designed for customization. It doesn't need to contain anything you don't use frequently. Allows for paradigms like where you can customize each home screen for one function - for e.g., I have one for communication (gtalk, whatsapp, facebook), one for media (music widget, youtube, gallery, camera etc.) and more.

My communication home screen on Samsung Galaxy S2 (I am using Go Launcher here, but this type of customization is common to all androids, including ICS).

2. Has widgets. Significantly reduces effort to read facebook updates, next calender entry, turning on bluetooth etc. Windows Phone 7 also has dynamic tiles for this purpose. iOS is the only laggard, and it also gives rise to problems: like how hard it is to change brightness or turn bluetooth, gps on or off.

Widget to toggle settings - WiFi, Bluetooth, GPS, Sync and Brightness.  Screen shot from a Froyo phone.


3. Presence of fixed back button gives a consistency to the UI. It is heavily used.

4. The App drawer lists apps sorted by name, instead of sorted by time of installation. This makes finding an app much faster (computer engineers would remember that in a sorted array, binary search is possible, which takes O(log N) compared to O(N) time complexity for linear search).
5. App Switcher soft button is directly visible - easily discoverable and easier to use than the double click of home button of iOS. Furthermore, there are screen previews instead of just icons

6. Gmail UI is far superior to iOS email.
  • Going to different account or folder/label takes less taps in Android (though it is not totally obvious that "xyz@gmail.com" or "Inbox" are clickable buttons).
  • Select squares are present by default - makes it easy performing an action to multiple emails. Ditto for starring.
  • Try reading a long conversation. Android vs iOS comparison is like Heaven vs Hell.
  • Reading consecutive mails is so easy, using swipe right gesture.
7. Android has a search box visible in each home screen. In iOS its like a treasure hunt, you have to swipe beyond the left most home screen, giving the tiniest possible clue - a tiny lens icon to the left of dots identifying which home screen you are on.

8. Subjective: I like the fact that android’s scrolling conserves momentum if you "push" hard. iOS artificially applies brakes on the scrolling, no matter how hard you push it.

9. If you don’t like the UI, and are willing to invest some time, you can change it via the numerable apps available in the market for that purpose. I would argue that this fosters innovation in UI. Just look at all the research that has happened in on screen keyboard area since android launch. Swype sold for $102M!
iOS scores over Android:


iOS 5 homescreen, with tiny counts for unread items for some apps.

1. Complexity of the home screen model in Android: the separation of home screens and app drawer brings complications:
  • A novice needs to understand the difference, and be made aware of the app drawer icon to view all apps.
  • The point is to customize your home screens. Not everyone is willing to make that effort. For them, a tap on app drawer just adds an extra tap to get to an app.
  • Adding an app or widget through long presses is not easily discoverable (though new phones have a little “teacher” widget on the home screen which teaches few basic things like this.)
Android can help mitigate this if it allows for an "unlock to Apps" option in the unlock screen (like you can unlock to camera in ICS), and keep the bottom dock of essential apps visible in the app drawer too.

2. In Android, once notifications are cleared, you dont know if you still have unread email, messages or missed calls. You can selectively clear notifications which partially takes care of the problem. iOS wins here with its tiny unread number icons.

3. I think how to open the lock screen is a bit more obvious in iOS than in Android.

Coverflow UI for navigating albums in iOS

4. Music app's coverflow is not only cool, it also makes obvious how to navigate through gestures and shows results visually. Android still can't match this.

Both Suck:

1. Both rely quite a bit on icons which don't have text labels to explain their meaning, and not always is the icon's purpose obvious. Andriod starts at the home screen - the bottom dock of icons have no labels, nor do the 3 navigational soft buttons (back, home, app switcher). The send arrow button in email or messaging has no label. iOS has this problem occasionally - the biggest example is the 5 icons at the bottom in the browser.







2. Many times some menu or other navigational item is positioned at the top of the screen. It is not ideal because it is harder for the thumb to reach the top part of the screen - when using the phone with one hand. Android is better than iOS here because there is at least a back button at the bottom.

Conclusion

From the counts, looks like Android won! But the counts deceive you - because some issues are more important than others.
With the launch of Ice Cream Sandwich, the separation of home screen and app drawer remains the biggest reason for Android's complexity over iOS. Gingerbread had more issues: options hidden in hardware menu button, too much reliance on long press, tab switching in browser, a complicated settings screen etc. But with Ice Cream Sandwich, Google has recognized and fixed these issues. A detailed comparison between Nexus S running gingerbread and Galaxy Nexus running ICS is the topic of another post in the future, when I get my hands on the Galaxy Nexus.


I would say iOS continues to be easier to use, simply because there is no discovery to be done before you find all your apps. This is one of the core differentiating factors of Android vs iOS and I doubt if Android will ever move to iOS model or vice versa. This difference is here to stay, and as a result I believe users seeking utmost simplicity will always remain customers of Apple, and others looking to be able to customize their phone for faster daily usage will flock to Android.

Of course, a complete experience depends on many more things, like the apps available, other services in the eco system, the hardware etc. Stay tuned for analysis of these aspects in the future.

Another blog on Tech commentary?

Do we really need another point of view for all the happenings in Tech industry? Yes, we do! Because last 9 out of 10 articles I read about iPhone 4S or Galaxy Nexus were biased due to writer's own allegiance. Because I've read hundreds of times that Android is less consistent and user friendly than iOS, but nobody goes on to explain how. Go down to comments, and this confusion gets magnified between the Wars of the Fanboys.

Hence, Fanboys Not Allowed! Tech commentary which is objective and where conclusions have a basis.